How comedian Howie Mandel almost quit show business — and ended up changing television instead

In 2005, Howie Mandel, a Toronto native, was going through one of the darkest stretches of his career. Another TV project had flopped, and the comedian was exhausted by the “Hollywood games” — so much so that he was seriously considering walking away from the industry for good. His career felt like a dead end with no way out. That was precisely the moment when an offer arrived that he found utterly absurd.
Mandel told this story in an interview on Q, speaking with host Tom Power and candidly recalling every detail of that pivotal chapter in his life.
The nail in the coffin
Mandel was offered the hosting job on a new game show called Deal or No Deal, in which contestants would choose from 26 briefcases containing unknown sums of money. He turned it down immediately. By his own account, for someone whose currency had always been irony and humor, hosting a game show felt like a professional death sentence. And when he was told the program would air in prime time five evenings in a row, the sense of impending disaster only grew stronger.
The producers, however, were not ready to give up. An hour after his refusal, they called back, insisting the project couldn’t happen without him. Mandel held firm and even refused to come into the office. So the show’s representative took an unconventional approach.
An impromptu game at a deli
The producer flew out personally to a deli (San Fernando Valley), where Mandel happened to be at the time. He brought along a cardboard mock-up of the show and proposed that the comedian play through it right there in the restaurant, among the tables and other diners. The scene looked more like a comedy sketch than a business negotiation. Nevertheless, the show’s format was demonstrated, and the pressure on Mandel became almost tangible.
When he got home, he recounted the whole story to his wife. Her response turned out to be surprisingly practical and straightforward. Since he already believed his career was in decline, he had nothing to lose. That argument proved decisive, and Mandel agreed.
A shame-fueled vacation and 100 million viewers
In December 2005, Deal or No Deal went on air. By that point, Mandel had flown off to the Caribbean — he was that embarrassed by the project. He had no desire to be in the US, where he lived, and witness people’s reactions to the show.
Then the phone rang — it was that same producer from the deli. In the first week of broadcast, across five episodes, the show had been watched by 100 million viewers. Mandel came back immediately. His flight landed in Miami, and literally 30 seconds after he stepped into the airport, the first person to spot him called out “Deal or no deal?” The show he had considered a career killer had made him one of the most recognizable TV hosts in America.
A new era of comedians at the helm
The show’s massive ratings demonstrated something simple yet revolutionary to the networks: a comedian hosting a game show doesn’t just work — it delivers enormous audiences. That changed the rules of the game for the entire industry.
In the wake of Deal or No Deal’s success, a whole wave of game shows with comedians at the helm followed. Among the most notable examples:
- Steve Harvey became the host of Family Feud
- Jeff Foxworthy took the helm of Are You Smarter than a Fifth Grader?
Mandel himself comments on his contribution to this trend with characteristic self-deprecating humor. “All those comedians you see hosting game shows now? You’re welcome.”
Notably, the influence of this trend has extended well beyond broadcast television. According to industry data, live game shows are experiencing a new surge in popularity in the online space. Major gaming platforms are creating interactive live-hosted shows, and revenues in the segment are growing fast enough that companies can afford to bring in celebrities to boost their profile. This is what the authors of a review site covering live game shows told us when we spoke with them while preparing this article.
The formula that Mandel accidentally proved in 2005 keeps on working: a charismatic host transforms a simple mechanic into a spectacle people actually want to watch. So it turns out the journey from a cardboard mock-up in a deli to a global trend was shorter than anyone could have imagined.
Mandel stays on air
Today, Howie Mandel’s career is a far cry from where it stood twenty years ago. He continues to serve as a judge on America’s Got Talent, whose 21st season kicks off on June 2. In addition, this fall he will appear as a judge on Canada’s Got Talent and as host of The Price Is Right Tonight. Both projects are returning to air after a hiatus.
